• Slide Background Image
    Authentic Coal Fired Flavor
    Savor the Tradition
    Experience the distinctive taste of Lenny's
    unique coal-fired pizzas, crafted with care.
  • Slide Background Image
    Customizable Pizza Delights
    Your Pizza, Your Way
  • Slide Background Image
    Warm Hospitality & Service
    Feel at Home Here
    Enjoy not just great food but also friendly
    service that keeps customers coming back for more.
Background

People talk

Our Guestbook

Discover Full Menu
Background
43694
Reviews
4.8
Ratings
67
in Menu
43564
Positive Reviews

About

Lenny's Coal Fired Pizza

Welcome to Lenny's Coal Fired Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the vibrant heart of Valparaiso, Indiana. Located at 3800 N Calumet Ave, this culinary destination is making a name for itself with its unique approach to pizza that marries traditional coal-fired cooking techniques with modern flavors.

Upon entering Lenny's, you're enveloped in the warm and inviting ambiance that promises an exceptional dining experience. The focus here is, of course, on the pizza, and the menu offers a variety that is as extensive as it is delectable. Each pie is characterized by its perfectly charred crust, a hallmark of coal-fired cooking that adds a tantalizing depth of flavor.

  • The Wings: Cooked to perfection, the 8 baked wings allow you to select from a variety of sauces or rubs for just US$14.00.
  • The Calzones: These stuffed delights come in various styles, including the classic BYO Calzone starting at US$12.00. Specialty options like Michael's White Pie and BBQ Chicken Pie, priced up to US$18.00, showcase fresh ingredients like mozzarella, ham, and chicken.
  • Beverages: Pair your meal with a range of Coke products, available for US$3.95, to quench your thirst perfectly.

Lenny's also caters to customization, allowing you to craft your own pizza or calzone according to your palate. Patrons often rave about the unique toppings and enticing combinations, such as jalapenos paired with a drizzle of honey, a bold choice that keeps bringing customers back for more.

Customer testimonials speak volumes about the quality of food and warmth of service at Lenny’s. Ben Spillner remarked on the incredible food and excellent service, while Karl Merkner was pleasantly surprised by the solid pizza and delectable fried pickled spears. Frequent visitors, like Chillz Life, love the distinct coalfire taste and the welcoming ethos of the staff—that kind of hospitality makes all the difference.

Whether you're a die-hard pizza enthusiast or just in search of a great meal, Lenny's promises a satisfying experience that exceeds expectations. The casual dining atmosphere, together with friendly interactions, adds to the charm that keeps the table bustling with happy diners. For anyone visiting the area, Lenny's Coal Fired Pizza is a must-try destination that beckons you to savor each mouthful.

In conclusion, Lenny's stands out not only for its exquisite offerings but also for its genuine commitment to customer satisfaction. Bring your friends and family and prepare for a delightful pizza adventure!

Background

Book a table

Make A Reservation

You can Book a table online easily in just a couple of minutes. Just check the availability of your table & book it now!